The layoff mistake that can cost you top talent

people2people • 9 April 2026

Workforce reductions are often treated as short-term business decisions, but their effects can last far beyond the day the news is delivered. When layoffs are handled poorly, organisations risk more than immediate disruption. They can weaken trust, damage morale, increase unwanted turnover, and create a negative reputation that lingers in the market.


For HR leaders, the challenge is not only managing the process itself but also reducing the impact on those who leave and those who remain. A poorly handled restructure can leave employees feeling uncertain, undervalued, and disconnected from the organisation’s future. That creates a ripple effect across culture, engagement, and retention.


Research highlighted in the article shows that internal fallout can be significant. Nearly four in 10 employees said layoffs harmed their perception of their employer, while more than one in five said they would be unlikely to stay after layoffs occur. HR leaders also reported that layoffs can increase voluntary turnover, with high-performing employees often among the first to leave.


That matters because when top performers exit, organisations do not just lose headcount. They lose expertise, momentum, leadership capability, and valuable institutional knowledge. Teams can feel unsettled, productivity can drop, and the wider business may struggle to regain confidence.


The external impact can be just as serious. Employees are increasingly willing to share negative experiences online, whether through professional networks, employer review sites, or community forums. That means a single poorly managed process can shape how future candidates, customers, and stakeholders view an organisation for months or even years.


This is where communication becomes critical. Employees affected by layoffs want honesty, clarity, and respect. Those who remain also need reassurance about the direction of the business, what changes are coming next, and how leadership will support them through uncertainty. Many employees felt organisations could have been more transparent, offered earlier notice, provided clearer timelines, and improved career transition support.


Handled well, layoffs do not become painless, but they can become less damaging. Transparent communication, visible leadership, wellbeing support, career development for remaining staff, and practical transition support for departing employees all help reduce the aftershocks. Support such as severance, extended benefits, and outplacement can make a real difference to how employees experience the process and how they speak about it afterwards.


For HR teams, the message is clear. Layoffs are not only an operational or financial event. They are also a people, culture, and brand moment. Organisations that approach them with empathy, structure, and clarity are more likely to protect trust, retain key talent, and rebuild confidence after change. Those that do not may find the real cost continues long after the restructure is complete.

Grow your career and teams with people2people


In business since 2005 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2025 RCSA and SEEK Outstanding Large Agency Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.

Recent articles

by people2people 7 April 2026
Your talent pipeline may be full, but that does not mean the right people are applying. Here is why AI is making hiring harder and what employers can do to improve candidate quality.
by people2people 31 March 2026
Explore how performance management can become a psychosocial hazard and what employers can do to create clearer, safer, and more supportive workplace conversations.
by people2people 23 March 2026
Why employees hide stress at work, the warning signs managers miss, and how employers can create a safer culture that supports early conversations and better wellbeing.

Latest PR features