Can an Employee Facing Criminal Charges Be Terminated?

Colin Sloan • May 12, 2019

We can thank the “bad boys” of Rugby League (NSW) for putting this thorny issue back under the spotlight.

The St George Illawarra Rugby League club came under scrutiny recently for suspending star player Jack de Belin after he was charged with a serious criminal offence. Some may ask, why didn’t the Club simply terminate his employment at that time?

If an employee is charged with a criminal offence, does that justify the termination of the employment relationship? What is the relevance of the “presumption of innocence” in these circumstances?

Often a contract of employment will contain a clause (especially for more senior positions) which allows the employer to terminate the employment if the employee is charged with an offence which, in the opinion of the employer, is likely to bring the employer’s business into disrepute. It is not known whether De Belin’s contract included a similar clause.

However, what if there is no such clause?

Can a small business owner, for example, dismiss an employee who has been charged with (but not yet convicted of) a serious crime?

The case of Deeth v Milly Hill Pty Ltd (2015) involved an apprentice butcher who was dismissed after being charged with the offence of accessory after the fact to murder. The employer argued that the summary dismissal was justified as the business was located in a small country town and the employee’s charges were likely to have a serious impact on the reputation and profitability of the business.

The Fair Work Commission stated;

what an employee does on his or her own time is a matter for him or her. There is no presumption that a criminal conviction alone is a valid reason for termination of employment, particularly where the criminal offence was committed outside of work. Even conduct outside of work involving criminal offences does not, alone, warrant dismissal ”.

The Commission found that, whilst it was reasonable for the employer to have concerns regarding the impact the charges would have on its business, the fact the dismissal was carried out summarily, without affording the employee procedural fairness, rendered the dismissal harsh and unjust. Mr Deeth received six weeks’ wages in compensation. This correspondent does not know if he also beats the accessory rap.

What can employers learn from this case? Firstly, that a criminal charge does not, by itself, justify dismissal. The relevant question is – what is the risk of harm to the employer arising from the charges? Even if this risk exists, the employee must still be afforded procedural fairness (ie. given an opportunity to respond) before any decision regarding dismissal is reached.

Colin Sloan has been a lawyer for over 20 years. After graduating from the University of New South Wales Law School in 1995, he was admitted to practice as a Solicitor. Colin has worked in a variety of legal and commercial roles during his career. Using the extensive experience gained whilst working as an in-house lawyer and commercial manager for large organisations, he now helps business clients navigate the legal and commercial landscape.

Find the job you love I Find the right talent
Get in touch with people2people

Australia
   I    United Kingdom

In business since 2002 in Australia, NZ, and the United Kingdom, people2people is an award-winning recruitment agency with people at our heart. With over 12 offices, we specialise in accounting and finance, business support, education, executive, government, HR, legal, marketing and digital, property, sales, supply chain, and technology sectors. As the proud recipients of the 2024 Outstanding Large Agency and Excellence in Candidate Care Awards, we are dedicated to helping businesses achieve success through a people-first approach.

Recent articles

By people2people UK September 22, 2025
In 2025, UK marketing teams face a critical turning point. As technology like AI and automation reshape how campaigns are delivered, the demand for data-driven strategy, personalisation, and authentic engagement is higher than ever.
Calculator, pen, and financial documents with numbers and a graph.
By people2people UK September 15, 2025
The accounting industry is facing a growing talent crisis, with 94% of firms reporting that recruitment challenges are limiting their ability to grow. Staff shortages, an ageing workforce, and rising salary pressures are driving a shift toward outsourcing, offshoring, and tech investment.
Big Ben clock tower and Westminster Bridge in London, England.
By Liz Jones September 8, 2025
A workplace culture writer specialising in employee wellbeing, flexible working trends, and HR innovation. Helping organisations create healthier, more productive work environments through trusted insights and data-driven content.
By Liz Jones August 27, 2025
The latest data shows that the UK labour market continues to perform steadily in 2025, with employment levels holding firm and job vacancies remaining historically high. While pay growth has slowed slightly, overall workforce activity remains strong, supported by high participation and resilient hiring demand. Liz Jones, Recruitment Director at people2people UK, says that this steady picture aligns closely with trends identified in the firm’s 2025 UK Market Report. “We are still seeing a healthy labour market,” she explains. “Employment is growing, and job openings remain strong, especially in sectors such as healthcare, logistics and professional services.” Employment Rate Rises, Unemployment Falls According to the July 2025 bulletin, the UK employment rate rose to 76.4 percent, the highest in over a year. The unemployment rate dropped to 3.7 percent, a level not seen since early 2020. This marks continued improvement in labour force participation following a volatile period during the pandemic recovery. Jones notes that this trend is being felt across multiple industries. "Businesses are rebuilding workforces and candidates are returning to the labour market," she says. "It is encouraging to see stronger engagement from both employers and jobseekers." Pay Growth Slows but Remains Positive One notable shift in the July update is a softening of pay growth. Annual wage increases for the period stood at 5.2 percent, down from 6.1 percent earlier in the year. This reflects a more balanced economic climate as inflation eases and employers stabilise budgets. “While pay growth is slowing, it is still above historical averages,” Jones comments. “Employers are adjusting to cost pressures, but most remain committed to offering competitive salaries to retain talent.” Vacancies Stay High, Reflecting Continued Demand Despite slower wage growth, the number of job vacancies remains elevated. Sectors such as care, education, and IT continue to post consistent hiring demand, with temporary and contract roles seeing a modest rise in 2025. “Our market report shows that employers are being more selective, but they are still hiring,” says Jones. “The competition for skilled talent is keeping demand steady, especially for roles that require specialist expertise or qualifications.” Implications for Employers With a stable employment base and slower but sustained pay growth, Jones suggests that now is a critical time for companies to refine their recruitment strategies. She recommends: Reviewing salary benchmarking to stay competitive in priority roles Streamlining recruitment processes to reduce vacancy durations Investing in retention through training and internal mobility Enhancing employer branding to attract passive candidates “The market is not slowing down,” she says. “It is settling. Employers who respond with clarity and flexibility will continue to secure great talent.” Summary The July 2025 labour market update confirms a period of stability for the UK workforce. While pay increases are moderating, employment levels remain high and hiring activity continues across core sectors. For recruitment leaders, this is a time to invest in strategy, not to pull back. With the right planning, employers can navigate this market with confidence.
By Liz Jones August 20, 2025
Pressure to Return to the Office Is Driving Resentment Among UK Workers As flexible working continues to define the future of employment, new findings suggest the UK may be facing a growing disconnect between employer expectations and employee preferences. According to people2people UK’s 2025 Market Report, more than half of workers feel increasing pressure to spend additional time in the office, a shift that is impacting engagement and retention across multiple sectors. Liz Jones, Recruitment Director at people2people UK, says that rigid workplace policies are now a leading contributor to candidate reluctance and employee churn. "Our data shows that 54 percent of UK employees feel pushed to return to the office more than they want to," she explains. "This pressure is not just inconvenient. It is reshaping how people view their current roles and future opportunities." Where the Pressure Comes From The 2025 Market Report found that much of the drive to return to the office stems from top leadership, with executive teams leading the call for more on-site presence. This push is not always aligned with performance metrics or employee feedback. "This is not about output or productivity," says Jones. "It is about outdated assumptions. Leadership often equates visibility with value, but that mindset is increasingly out of step with how modern teams work best." The mismatch between executive expectations and employee needs is contributing to declining morale, particularly in office-based roles that could easily operate on a hybrid basis. Flexibility Still Matters Despite the push to increase office attendance, flexibility remains a top priority for candidates and employees. The Market Report confirms that roles offering flexible working continue to receive more applications, fill faster, and maintain lower turnover rates. "Flexibility is not a temporary trend," Jones adds. "It is now a standard part of what professionals expect. Candidates are telling us clearly that how they work matters just as much as where or for whom." The data reveals that teams which embrace flexible models tend to report stronger engagement, better collaboration, and improved retention outcomes, especially in sectors such as tech, finance, and professional services. What Employers Should Do To stay competitive, Jones advises that employers need to reevaluate their return-to-office strategies with both data and empathy in mind. people2people UK recommends: Involving employees in setting attendance expectations Tailoring policies by role, function, and team needs Communicating the reasons for on-site requirements clearly and consistently Measuring the impact of attendance policies on productivity and engagement "One-size-fits-all approaches no longer work," Jones notes. "Companies that listen to their teams and create flexibility within structure will outperform those that rely on top-down mandates." Looking Ahead As the labour market continues to evolve, the ability to offer meaningful flexibility will be a deciding factor in who attracts and retains top talent. The 2025 UK Market Report shows a strong correlation between adaptive working policies and long-term business resilience. "Employers have a choice," Jones concludes. "They can lead with trust and flexibility, or risk losing great people to those who do."

Latest Media Features


Get in touch

Find out more by contacting one of our specialisat recruitment consultants across Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom.

Contact us